How to stop phishing-report overload in Microsoft Defender
When employees report suspicious emails, they help protect everyone. The more they report, the better. But on Microsoft's default settings, every report can land in your IT team's inbox as a new email. There is no difference between "already handled" and "this needs a person". This guide shows you how to let Microsoft handle the routine, so you only hear about the reports that need you.
How to use this guide
You only need to read one part of this guide: the part for your Microsoft license. How much Microsoft can handle for you depends on your Defender plan, so the steps are different for each plan.
- Find your plan in the table below.
- Click the link to go to the guide for your plan.
- Follow the steps from top to bottom. You can skip the rest of the post.
Every step is done in the Microsoft Defender portal (security.microsoft.com). You don't need scripts or deep Defender experience.
|
Your plan |
You have this plan if you have |
What Microsoft does automatically |
How you hear about what matters |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Exchange Online Protection only. For example Microsoft 365 Business Basic or Standard, Office 365 E1 or E3, or Microsoft 365 E3 without a Defender for Office 365 add-on |
Removes emails later found to be malicious. Analyzes every report and shows Microsoft's verdict |
A person looks at every report: an email per report (E3) or a daily look at the reports |
|
|
Microsoft 365 Business Premium, or Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 |
As Basic, plus protection of links and attachments (Safe Links and Safe Attachments) |
An email per report to one shared mailbox, plus an email about serious incidents |
|
|
Defender for Office 365 Plan 2, Office 365 E5, Microsoft 365 E5, or Microsoft Defender Suite (formerly E5 Security), also as an add-on to Business Premium |
Investigates every report, removes the email from every inbox and tells the employee the result |
Only an email about incidents that need a person |
Not sure which plan you have? In the Defender portal, go to Settings → Email & collaboration. If you see MDO automation settings, you have Plan 2. If you don't, check your licenses in the Microsoft 365 admin center under Billing → Licenses.
Good to know: Microsoft 365 Business Premium includes Plan 1, not Plan 2. Automatic investigation and clean-up need Plan 2 or an E5 license.
Mixed licenses? Plan 2 automation only fully covers the employees who have a Plan 2 license. Follow the guide for the plan that covers most of your employees, usually Plan 2. Its step 9 explains how to cover the employees without a Plan 2 license.
Why the safety net matters
Each guide sets up as much automation as your licenses allow. It also makes sure you are still told about the things automation can't handle. Automation without a safety net only means that the gaps go unnoticed.
Use these guides as inspiration, not a fixed recipe. Your licenses, mail setup, security team and risk appetite decide what is right for you. Check Microsoft's own guidance, linked at each step, and adapt or skip anything that doesn't fit. Microsoft also renames settings and changes features, so what you see in your portal may be different.
Guide for Basic: Exchange Online Protection only
Microsoft removes emails it later finds to be malicious and gives each report a verdict. It does not investigate reports or clean up other inboxes on its own. So a person needs to look at every report. These steps make that as easy as possible.
Step 1: Set up reporting the standard way
- Go to Settings → Email & collaboration → User reported settings.
- Check that Monitor reported messages in Outlook is on, and that employees use Microsoft's built-in Report button in Outlook.
- Under Reported message destinations, choose Microsoft only. Microsoft then analyzes every report. If your security team needs its own copy, you can also add a reporting mailbox.
- Recommended: under Customize messages, add a short thank-you that employees see after they report. For example: "Thank you. The message has been reported and will be checked. Every report helps protect your colleagues."
Microsoft's guide: User reported settings
Step 2: Keep automatic removal of malicious emails on
Zero-hour auto purge (ZAP) removes emails from inboxes when Microsoft later finds them to be malicious. That includes emails employees have reported or deleted. It is on by default.
- Go to Email & collaboration → Policies & rules → Threat policies.
- Open your Anti-spam and Anti-malware policies and check that zero-hour auto purge is on. We recommend leaving it on.
Microsoft's guide: Zero-hour auto purge
Step 3: Make sure someone sees every report
- Go to Email & collaboration → Policies & rules → Alert policy and look for Email reported by user as malware or phish. Office 365 and Microsoft 365 E3 include it. Business Basic and Standard don't.
- If you have it: open it, turn on email notifications and add one shared mailbox instead of each admin. Reports that arrive within 15 minutes of each other are grouped into one alert. Keep this email on: it is likely your only signal that a report exists.
- If you don't: make it a daily habit to open Actions & submissions → Submissions → User reported. Microsoft's verdict is in the Result column. Act on anything marked as phishing or malware.
Microsoft's guide: Alert policies
Step 4 (optional): Tell employees the result
Under Submissions → User reported, select a report and use Mark as and notify. Without Plan 2, this is a manual step.
Microsoft's guide: Reviewing reported messages
Step 5: Cover what no tool can see
No tool can see that someone typed their password into a fake page. Make sure employees know to tell IT straight away if they clicked a suspicious link or entered their login details.
Curious what Plan 2 would automate for you? See the Plan 2 guide.
Guide for Plan 1, including Business Premium
You get an alert for every report, but Microsoft does not investigate and clean up for you. So keep the email for each report, send it to one place, and add an email about serious incidents.
Step 1: Set up reporting the standard way
- Go to Settings → Email & collaboration → User reported settings.
- Check that Monitor reported messages in Outlook is on, and that employees use Microsoft's built-in Report button in Outlook.
- Under Reported message destinations, choose Microsoft only. Microsoft then analyzes every report. If your security team needs its own copy, you can also add a reporting mailbox.
- Recommended: under Customize messages, add a short thank-you that employees see after they report. For example: "Thank you. The message has been reported and will be checked. Every report helps protect your colleagues."
Microsoft's guide: User reported settings
Step 2: Keep automatic removal of malicious emails on
Zero-hour auto purge (ZAP) removes emails from inboxes when Microsoft later finds them to be malicious. That includes emails employees have reported or deleted. It is on by default.
- Go to Email & collaboration → Policies & rules → Threat policies.
- Open your Anti-spam and Anti-malware policies and check that zero-hour auto purge is on. We recommend leaving it on.
Microsoft's guide: Zero-hour auto purge
Step 3: Send the report email to one shared mailbox
- Go to Email & collaboration → Policies & rules → Alert policy and open Email reported by user as malware or phish.
- Turn on email notifications and add one shared mailbox instead of each admin. Save.
Reports that arrive within 15 minutes of each other are grouped into one alert. Don't turn this email off. With Plan 1, it is usually your only signal that a report exists.
Microsoft's guide: Alert policies
Step 4: Add an email about serious incidents
Business Premium includes this. If you don't see Microsoft Defender XDR under Settings, skip this step.
- Go to Settings → Microsoft Defender XDR → Email notifications, open the Incidents tab and select Add incident notification rule. Give it a name.
- Under Notification settings, choose the service source Microsoft Defender for Office 365 with alert severity High and Medium. Select Send only one notification per incident.
- Under Recipients, add at least two people or a shared mailbox, so it never depends on one person.
- Select Send test email, check that it arrives and select Create rule.
Why High and Medium: High covers, for example, an account that forwards email to a suspicious address or is blocked from sending. Medium includes cases where Microsoft found a malicious email but could not remove it.
Microsoft's guide: Incident notifications by email
Step 5 (optional): Tell employees the result
Under Submissions → User reported, select a report and use Mark as and notify. Without Plan 2, this is a manual step.
Step 6: Cover what no tool can see
No tool can see that someone typed their password into a fake page. Make sure employees know to tell IT straight away if they clicked a suspicious link or entered their login details.
What upgrading to Plan 2 would change
Plan 2 investigates every report, removes the email from every inbox, answers the employee automatically and lets you turn off the email for each report. Microsoft offers a free 90-day trial of Plan 2 in the Defender portal under Trials.
Guide for Plan 2 or E5: automate, and only hear about what needs a person
Microsoft can investigate every report, clean up every inbox and answer the employee for you. Follow the steps in order. That way, the email for each report is only turned off once the targeted incident email is working.
Step 1: Set up reporting the standard way
- Go to Settings → Email & collaboration → User reported settings.
- Check that Monitor reported messages in Outlook is on, and that employees use Microsoft's built-in Report button in Outlook.
- Under Reported message destinations, choose Microsoft only. Microsoft then analyzes every report. If your security team needs its own copy, you can also add a reporting mailbox.
- Recommended: under Customize messages, add a short thank-you that employees see after they report. For example: "Thank you. The message has been reported and will be checked. Every report helps protect your colleagues."
Microsoft's guide: User reported settings
Step 2: Keep automatic removal of malicious emails on
Zero-hour auto purge (ZAP) removes emails from inboxes when Microsoft later finds them to be malicious. That includes emails employees have reported or deleted. It is on by default.
- Go to Email & collaboration → Policies & rules → Threat policies.
- Open your Anti-spam and Anti-malware policies and check that zero-hour auto purge is on. We recommend leaving it on.
Microsoft's guide: Zero-hour auto purge
Step 3: Turn on automatic clean-up
- Go to Settings → Email & collaboration → MDO automation settings.
- Under Message clusters, select Similar files, Similar URLs and Multiple similar attributes.
- Under Remediation action, keep Soft delete (the only option). Emails can be recovered. Select Save.
Built-in safety rail: a cluster of more than 10,000 emails is never cleaned up automatically. It waits for your approval (see step 8).
Microsoft's guide: Automated remediation in AIR
Step 4: Let Microsoft answer employees automatically
- Go to Settings → Email & collaboration → User reported settings.
- Under Email notifications → Results email, select Automatically email users the results of the investigation. Then select Phishing or malware, Spam and No threats found.
- Optional: select Customize results email to add your own wording. Select Save.
Employees now get a "we checked it, and here's what we found" email, so they keep reporting. For phishing or malware, the email is sent once the clean-up is done.
Microsoft's guide: Automatic user notifications
Step 5: Add one targeted email about incidents that need a person
- Go to Settings → Microsoft Defender XDR → Email notifications, open the Incidents tab and select Add incident notification rule. Give it a name.
- Under Notification settings, choose the service source Microsoft Defender for Office 365 with alert severity High and Medium. Select Send only one notification per incident.
- Under Recipients, add at least two people or a shared mailbox, so it never depends on one person.
- Select Send test email, check that it arrives and select Create rule.
Why High and Medium: High covers, for example, an employee clicking a malicious link or an account forwarding email to a suspicious address. Medium includes cases where Microsoft found a malicious email but could not remove it. That is exactly when automation has failed.
Microsoft's guide: Incident notifications by email
Step 6: Turn off the email for each report
- Go to Email & collaboration → Policies & rules → Alert policy and open Email reported by user as malware or phish.
- Turn off its email notifications (Opt-in for email notifications) and save.
Turn off the email, not the policy. Leave the policy itself On. It starts Microsoft's investigation of each report and the results email to employees, and it keeps a record of every report.
Step 7: Check the threshold against your own history (5 minutes)
- Go to Incidents & alerts → Incidents. Filter on the service source Microsoft Defender for Office 365 and severity High and Medium, over the last three to six months.
- A handful per month or fewer: keep the rule as it is.
- Dozens or more: look at a sample. If most need no action, change the rule to High only.
- Zero: that is normal. It usually means nothing has needed a person, not that the rule is broken.
Step 8: Check decisions waiting for approval every week or two
Very large clusters (over 10,000 emails) and unclear cases wait in the Action center → Pending tab. Microsoft can't email you when something lands there, so make a habit of checking security.microsoft.com/action-center. It is usually empty, and that is the point.
Step 9: Cover what automation can't reach
- Employees without a Plan 2 license. Automatic investigation, clean-up and alerts about clicked malicious links only fully cover employees with a Plan 2 license. If some employees don't have one, keep someone looking at their reports.
- What only employees know. No tool can see that someone typed their password into a fake page. Make sure employees know to tell IT straight away if they clicked a suspicious link or entered their login details.
Two ways to reduce noise even further
- A quiet alert queue. Microsoft automatically resolves report alerts in the alert queue when its investigation finds nothing, and reopens them if it does. These built-in rules are under Settings → Microsoft Defender XDR → Alert tuning. Leave them on.
- AI triage (optional). With Security Copilot, Microsoft's Phishing Triage Agent can sort reported emails into real threats and false alarms. If you turn it on, Microsoft asks you to turn off the built-in rule "Auto-Resolve – Email reported by user as malware or phish". See Microsoft's guide.
Keep employees reporting
Less noise for IT should never mean fewer reports. Every report is an employee spotting something before it causes harm. That makes your employees your biggest resource against phishing. With Phishing Training, employees practice spotting and reporting phishing emails in their own inbox, so reporting becomes a habit.
Make it your own. These steps are suggestions based on Microsoft's recommended approach. If your setup, licenses or needs are different, check Microsoft's documentation and decide what works for your organization before you change any settings.
You will receive inspiration, tools and stories about good cyber security practice directly in your inbox. Our newsletter is sent out approximately once a month.